← Sound Encounters

chapter / 06

The politics of sound

If sound is real, it must be accounted for. And accounting can't happen outside politics. A sonic realism worth defending must go beyond metaphysics.

Sam Kendall Resonant Thoughts Personal record
Cover of Sound Encounters: Toward a Sonic Realism

Where sonic object mapping traced surface, behaviour, relationality and withholding, this chapter turns to power.

Who gets to sound? Who is heard? Whose sonic presence is silenced, denied, or extracted for the benefit of others?

In Western philosophy, truth has long been linked to vision: distant, detached, rational.

Sound, by contrast, is coded as immersive, emotional, unstable - and as such, suspect.

The visible is mapped. The audible is endured.

This division isn’t innocent. It has been weaponised to marginalise.

Sound has been racialised, feminised, criminalised. It has been marked as excessive or irrational.

Acoustic politics determine whose speech is legible as speech, whose sound is classified as disturbance, and whose sonic practices are permitted to exist in public space at all. The spatial dimension is real: sound is managed territory.

As Brandon LaBelle writes, acoustic politics are spatial politics.1 They govern who may speak, who must be silent, and which sonic behaviours are permitted in which zones - architectural, legal, digital.

Noise complaints, stop-and-search tactics, sound ordinances - all reveal how sonic space is managed unequally.

Meanwhile, sound is also romanticised - framed as pure affect, or unmediated truth.

This mystifies materiality and erases the structures through which sound operates as a system.

A sonic realism must resist both errors - reduction and mystification.

It must account for sound’s objecthood without universalising its availability.

Sound itself does not consent. People and communities do, and the conditions under which their sonic practices are heard, recorded, interpreted, or circulated matter.

Apply that lens to three sonic objects:

Three political objects

A protest chant

Surface: Rhythmic, collective, shouted, often fragmentary; repetitive, unstable, embodied.

Behaviour: Claims space, signals presence, disrupts normalcy; its force lies not in melody but in amplification of political presence.

Relationality: Situated in crowds, tense spaces, and legal risk; it interacts with police, press, livestreams, and bystanders - all part of its sonic infrastructure.

Withholding: May carry coded meanings or irony - not always for outsiders; some chants are deliberately resistant to full interpretation, and participants do not owe every listener an explanation.

Power: Acts politically through occupation, pressure, duration and collective presence.

A public alarm

Surface: High-pitched, repetitive, stripped of variation; designed not to be enjoyed but to override all ambient sound.

Behaviour: Forces action - evacuate, pause, respond; its force is directive, command-like; it doesn’t invite listening - it demands reaction.

Relationality: Tied to state infrastructure: fire alarms, curfews, security systems; intersects with institutional protocols and is interpreted differently based on context (e.g., worker, refugee, citizen).

Withholding: Offers no context; meaning is implied, not explained; presumes legibility - that everyone knows what it means; that is political.

Power: Coercive - built to act with authority, regardless of who’s listening or how they hear.

A public alarm and a protest chant can both interrupt the surrounding sound. The alarm relies on institutional authority to tell people what to do. A chant gathers force from what people say and the fact that they say it together. Who controls the source matters, as does who is within earshot and what it costs them to respond.

A long-range acoustic device (LRAD)

Surface: A focused, high-intensity output, often described as a piercing alarm; its effect varies with the device, setting, distance, and listener.

Behaviour: Coercive when used at harmful levels - it can cause pain and disorientation, disrupt bodies, and compel movement.7

Relationality: Deployed by police, military and private security forces during protests, border patrols and maritime conflicts; the effect of its output depends on the setting and the listener’s position.

Withholding: Someone who hears the tone may have little information about its source or setting.

Power: By weaponising sound, LRADs expose how sonic encounters are conditioned by authority; they show what happens when an institution can decide what others are made to hear.

These examples show different relations between sound, authority, and surveillance.

Sonic coercion and sonic resistance are both forms of encounter. An acoustic weapon acts on bodies without requiring their consent or comprehension; a protest chant can claim space through the force of collective presence as well as through its words.

To listen is to engage power.

Dylan Robinson’s theory of hungry listening exposes the extractive impulse that underlies settler-colonial relations to sound - the desire to capture, interpret, and make consumable that which was never offered.2

For Robinson, this mode of listening perpetuates a colonial epistemology, one that assumes entitlement to Indigenous expressions and encodes meaning within Western aesthetic and academic frameworks.

His call is for different listening: for settler subjects to encounter Indigenous sound as sovereign, and sometimes as withheld.

This refusal is not silence. It isn’t absence.

It’s a presence on its own terms.

Raven Chacon’s Voiceless Mass works with the organ and architecture of a Milwaukee cathedral. Chacon asks who has historically had access to that space and what it would mean for those in power to cede it.3

Hearing the work in a cathedral gives me no reason to assume everyone has been equally welcome there.

Listening, then, must sometimes mean not hearing. Or more precisely, not claiming.

In refusing the desire to decode or assimilate, sonic realism encounters sound as political in its structure of presentation and withdrawal.

Some sonic objects resist access for political reasons.

The people and communities who make them may not offer them to everyone.

To insist on their legibility is a kind of epistemic violence.

Nina Sun Eidsheim applies this critique to the racialised voice.4

She shows how timbre - often treated as a neutral texture - is coded through race, class, and gender.

What is heard as “too emotional” or “too loud” often reveals more about the listener’s prejudice than the sound itself.

Sara Ahmed reminds us that perception is always oriented.5 Some sounds are foregrounded, others dismissed.

Listening directs attention; it selects, foregrounds, and filters.

Taru Leppänen and Milla Tiainen bring intersectionality into the study of sound.6 I take that as a reason to ask how the conditions of an encounter bear on the sonic object.

Sound doesn’t exist outside of gender, race, disability, class, or ecological relation. Its objecthood is shaped by these forces. A siren sounds differently to someone undocumented.

A lullaby carries different meaning across generations and trauma.

A field recording in a rainforest carries extractive histories alongside its acoustic detail.

A sonic realism that attends to entanglement must also attend to accountability. To affirm that sound acts is to ask who bears the cost of that action, and the answer is rarely symmetrical. The same acoustic event lands differently depending on citizenship, race, proximity to the source, and access to institutional protection from harm.

Sonic realism must be situated.

Its realness is entangled in contested ground.

To affirm sound’s reality is to take responsibility for its effects.

To listen politically is to trace how sound is shaped, heard, ignored, or erased.

And who pays the cost.

Notes

  1. LaBelle, B. (2010) Acoustic Territories: Sound Culture and Everyday Life. London, Continuum.

  2. Robinson, D. (2020) Hungry Listening: Resonant Theory for Indigenous Sound Studies. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press.

  3. Chacon, R. (2021) Voiceless Mass [composition]. Recorded version on Voiceless Mass (2025), New World Records. https://www.newworldrecords.org/en-au/products/raven-chacon-voiceless-mass.

  4. Eidsheim, N. S. (2019) The Race of Sound: Listening, Timbre, and Vocality in African American Music. Durham, Duke University Press.

  5. Ahmed, S. (2006) Queer Phenomenology: Orientations, Objects, Others. Durham, Duke University Press.

  6. Leppänen, T. and Tiainen, M. ‘Intersectionality’, New Materialism Almanac. https://newmaterialism.eu/almanac/i/intersectionality.html.

  7. Goodman, S. (2010) Sonic Warfare: Sound, Affect, and the Ecology of Fear. Cambridge, MA, MIT Press.