We've claimed that sound is real.
Not a symbol. Not a metaphor.
A presence that insists, affects, withdraws.
Where the politics of sound argued that sonic realism must live inside power, this chapter stress-tests the claim itself.
But what does this realism entail? What might it obscure? Where does it need sharpening?
1. Naïve realism?
One risk is that sonic realism seems to promise too much: that we can access sound as it is, outside mediation. From Kant to Derrida, correlationist thinkers argue that we never encounter sound directly. We filter it - through perception, language, culture, memory. To ignore that is to ignore power.
Response: Sonic realism doesn't deny mediation.
It denies that mediation is all there is.
As Mandy-Suzanne Wong argues, sound's refusal to submit to meaning is not a sign of unreality - it's a sign of thingness.1
Sonic realism asserts that a sound can act whether or not we understand it. An encoding or a memory can remain after the sound has ended.
This is not naïve. It's ontologically modest.
2. Reverse reduction?
Another risk is that realism simply replaces perception with ontology, turning listening into a passive function of objecthood. In doing so, it threatens to flatten the labour of listening - the care, practice, and context involved in following sound.
Response: Listening is central to sonic realism. It is encounter, not decoding.
Sound is real, but listening is how we meet it - shaped by position, history, technique.
A sonic realism that ignores this isn’t realism. It’s reduction in another register.
3. The object trap
Calling sound an object lets us follow what it does over its duration. A sound can continue after one listener has gone, and its effects can outlast the sound itself.
Iain Campbell’s critique of Christoph Cox’s sonic materialism returns to Deleuze’s account of relations.2 The objection here is that calling sound an object might make a process seem like a thing.
Response: Only if we treat “object” as a static noun.
Sonic realism treats objecthood as operational: a structure that acts, not a thing that sits still.
A sonic object is durational, emergent, embedded.
We can follow what the sound changes while it lasts.
4. Is this political enough?
Why talk ontology when we need abolition, decolonisation, climate action? Is a metaphysics of the sonic object a distraction from what’s urgent?
Response: Ontology is never neutral.
To define what’s real is to define what matters - and who gets to matter.
Robinson and Eidsheim, developed at length in the previous chapter, make the same point from different angles: colonial systems define sound in ways that erase Indigenous sovereignty;3 voice is racialised long before it is heard.4
To affirm that sound is real - that it acts - is to insist that protest is not just communication. It’s intervention.
A chant isn’t only a form of expression. It’s spatial claim.
A racialised voice isn’t an aesthetic category. It’s a contested object, shaped by political power.
Sonic realism does not replace political analysis. It asks political analysis to account for what sound materially does as well as for how it is interpreted.
5. Whose realism?
The word realism carries weight. It suggests objectivity, neutrality, truth. But that is also a fiction.
Realism has a history - often used to universalise, to erase difference.
To affirm that sound is real does not grant neutral access to it. Sonic realism is situated: it acknowledges that all listening is trained, all access is partial, and what counts as music rather than noise has been determined by structures that sonic ontology must account for, not abstract away from.
Response: Sonic realism is not only a philosophical stance but also a practice.
It calls for modes of listening that cultivate attentiveness to sound’s agency while acknowledging our own positionality.
One such practice is the soundwalk, defined by composer and acoustic ecologist Hildegard Westerkamp as an excursion whose main purpose is listening to the environment.5
Here the walk is made without microphones or headphones, to attend to what the ear picks up along the way. It does not offer unfiltered access: bodies, histories, attention, and place still shape the encounter.
It opens ears to the unique characteristics of a place and heightens aural perception, revealing entanglements between listeners and their social, political and ecological contexts. By leaving room for sounds to emerge and disappear without immediate interpretation, soundwalking embodies a situated realism: it attends to presence and withdrawal, surface and relation, without assuming mastery.
Practices like this make sonic realism bodily: a way of moving through the world with reflection, care and responsibility.
So, what does sonic realism offer? A way to hear sound as participant.
It doesn’t ask what sound means.
It asks: what does sound do? How does it move? Where does it act? When does it hide?
It insists that sonic objects aren’t just heard. They are lived.
They shape attention, space, memory, and power.
Sonic realism is a practice as much as a position. The soundwalk, the listening session, the compositional encounter with an unfamiliar acoustic environment: these are instances of the theory, not illustrations of it. They demonstrate what it means to attend to sound as a force that acts on the listener before interpretation.
Graham Harman reminds us: objects exceed us.6
Sonic objects withdraw - never exhausted by any single hearing, recording, or inscription.
A waveform is not the sound, nor is perception the object.
To treat sound as object is to recognise this doubleness - presence and opacity, action and refusal.
Quentin Meillassoux’s speculative realism insists on a world unshackled from human access - a reality that continues without us.7 For sonic realism, this means sound must be thinkable even when unheard. Donna Haraway, by contrast, urges us to stay with the trouble - to resist transcendent claims and instead remain with entangled, partial relations.8
Between these positions, sonic realism finds its orientation: withdrawal and excess held together with situated listening as practice.
Sonic realism is an open orientation - and an ethics.
It asks us to listen differently.
To treat sound as neighbour.
As force. As encounter.
Notes
-
Wong, M.-S. (2020) ‘The Thingness of Sound’, Sonic Field, 11 September. Available at: https://sonicfield.org/the-thingness-of-sound-essay-by-mandy-suzanne-wong/ (Accessed: 26 July 2025).
-
Campbell, I. (2020) ‘Sound’s Matter: “Deleuzian Sound Studies” and the Problems of Sonic Materialism’, Contemporary Music Review, 39(5), pp. 618–637. https://doi.org/10.1080/07494467.2020.1852804.
-
Robinson, D. (2020) Hungry Listening: Resonant Theory for Indigenous Sound Studies. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press.
-
Eidsheim, N. S. (2019) The Race of Sound: Listening, Timbre, and Vocality in African American Music. Durham, Duke University Press.
-
Westerkamp, H. (1974) ‘Soundwalking’, Sound Heritage, 3(4), pp. 18 to 27.
-
Harman, G. (2011) The Quadruple Object. Winchester, Zero Books.
-
Meillassoux, Q. (2008) After Finitude: An Essay on the Necessity of Contingency. Translated by R. Brassier. London, Continuum.
-
Haraway, D. J. - Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Duke University Press, 2016.