Where from reduction to realism named sonic objects as open systems, this chapter turns to mapping them.
To attend to sound this way, we need mapping: a practice for tracing what sound does before it settles into meaning.
This is a provisional method rather than a scientific protocol: a repeatable practice of attention grounded in sonic realism.
This approach draws from object-oriented ontology (withdrawal), Deleuzian affect (force), intersectional critique (embeddedness), and decolonial and feminist epistemology (partiality).
It listens across surfaces and systems without claiming full access.
It maps how sonic objects emerge, behave, relate, and withhold.
Each dimension reflects a different orientation toward sound's reality:
- Surface (appearance)
Sound's phenomenological interface - what it seems to be.
How does it present itself, moment to moment? Is it smooth or jagged? Continuous or broken? What materials does it suggest - glass, breath, metal?
This reflects the sensory threshold - what the object lets us notice. Of course, it never tells the whole story.
- Behaviour (tendency and force)
Sound's operational profile - what it does.
Does it cut, sustain, agitate, lull? What kind of movement or response does it provoke? What systems or conditions does it act upon?
This echoes Deleuze's focus on affect - how a thing acts rather than the categories we assign to it.
The four dimensions of sonic mapping are not sequential stages in an analysis but simultaneous lenses, each of which makes different aspects of the object available. Attending to behaviour without relationality produces a description of force without context; attending to withholding without surface produces opacity without form. The practice requires all four to be held in parallel.
- Relationality (context and interaction)
Sound's embeddedness - where and how it operates.
What technologies shape it (microphones, speakers, software [e.g., Logic, Ableton, Max])? What social, political, or cultural structures does it interact with? What bodies, histories, or spaces are entangled with it?
This aligns with intersectional listening: sound doesn't emerge in a vacuum.
- Withholding (opacity and refusal)
What can you hear or infer from where you are? A recording can leave things out. A sound can be ambiguous. People can also decide who is allowed to hear or circulate a practice.
This honours object-oriented thought: no object is fully given.
To map a sonic object this way is to move alongside it.
To trace its operation across sensation, relation, and refusal.
To follow, not capture.
Let's test this by mapping a few common but radically different sonic objects:
Three sonic objects
A snare drum hit
Surface: Sharp transient, quick decay; piercing, midrange burst.
Behaviour: Punctuates rhythm; asserts presence; can startle or drive.
Relationality: Shaped by mic placement, mixing choices, genre norms.
Withholding: Evokes militarism or jungle breakbeats, but resists fixed meaning.
A force-event shaped by history and technology.
A thunderstorm
Surface: Rumbles, cracks, hiss - textured and layered.
Behaviour: Disrupts routine, commands attention, suspends activity.
Relationality: Mediated by architecture (walls, windows), media (film, recording), memory.
Withholding: Defies location or ownership; origin is diffuse; scale exceeds capture.
Acts through scale, risk, and immersion.
A voice note
You press play and hear the message.
Surface: Breath, glitch, cadence; compressed and intimate.
Behaviour: Interrupts digital silence; conveys care, urgency, or delay.
Relationality: Tied to social platforms (WhatsApp, iMessage); framed by sender-receiver dynamics.
Withholding: Pauses and hesitations leave the listener to interpret what the sender meant.
Relational: partial, affective, and situated.
Note: archival echoes
Every sonic object arrives mediated.
There is no unfiltered transmission - only inscriptions across layers of technology, memory, and decay.
A field recording is not the field. A voice note isn't the voice.
They are encodings. Material traces. Reproducible yet always partially withdrawn.
Archival mediation does not cancel the object's force; it changes the conditions under which surface, behaviour, relation, and withholding appear. The format is part of the encounter, not a veil over some prior purity.
This is not to diminish their reality. Quite the opposite.
A cassette's magnetic hiss, a MiniDisc's digital warble, the compressed sibilance of a low-bitrate MP3 - these belong to the sound itself, not to a degraded copy of some ideal.
A sonic object is always entangled with the medium through which it comes about and persists.
When we speak of "sonic realism", we must acknowledge that formats are ontological.
Formats participate in sound's becoming.
A recording made on shellac is not the same object as one made on magnetic tape. Each inhabits time differently.
Repeated plays can wear the grooves of shellac. Magnetic tape can deteriorate in storage.
Each carries its own temporality, its own archive of friction and fade.
This is where media archaeology meets the philosophy of sound. As Jonathan Sterne and Wolfgang Ernst argue, mediating formats are not neutral containers but ideological and material frameworks.1
The MP3, for instance, emerged from a history of bandwidth scarcity, psychoacoustic modelling, and perceptual compromise.
Its design depends on calculated absence - what a perceptual model predicts can be removed without being noticed.
That economy belongs to a history of constrained storage, bandwidth, speed, and commercial distribution. The format carries those conditions without being reducible to a single political meaning.
And yet it is real.
It structures how we hear, what we save, and what is lost.
To map a sonic object, then, is also to trace its media substrate: how it came to sound the way it does.
How it was shaped by microphones, cables, codecs, speakers, and silences.
Every echo is an archive.
And the archive, too, is an encounter.
With persistence. With the material memory of sound as it resounds, mutates, and endures through the media that carry it.
For records where these ideas meet actual materials, follow the selected creative practice.
Mapping as practice
A map can stay incomplete. Some details lie beyond the listener’s position. Other limits are set by the people whose practices are being heard.
This framework is a posture: repeatable, but never mechanical.
It draws from traditions that resist extraction and over-coding.
Donna Haraway reminds us that to map is never neutral.2
Dylan Robinson warns of hungry listening - the settler impulse to grasp and consume sound.3
Mapping must resist that hunger.
We need to acknowledge that some sonic practices are not offered for unrestricted hearing, and that makers or communities may withhold access from particular listeners.
Mandy-Suzanne Wong argues that sonic objects remain partially hidden - always escaping total access or comprehension.4
A map follows what can be heard and traced from a particular position.
Mapping becomes an ethics of following.
To map sound is to stay with its motion, its emergence, its opacity.
It is to ask: What does this sound do? Not just to us, but through us.
What does it touch? Where does it go? What does it refuse? And what might it become?
Every mapping risks extraction. Sonic realism has to carry its politics with its ontology.
Notes
-
Sterne, J. (2012) MP3: The Meaning of a Format. Durham, Duke University Press; Ernst, W. (2013) Digital Memory and the Archive. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press.
-
Haraway, D. J. (1988) 'Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective', Feminist Studies, 14(3), pp. 575 to 599.
-
Robinson, D. (2020) Hungry Listening: Resonant Theory for Indigenous Sound Studies. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press.
-
Wong, M.-S. (2020) 'The Thingness of Sound', Sonic Field, 11 September. Available at: https://sonicfield.org/the-thingness-of-sound-essay-by-mandy-suzanne-wong/ (Accessed: 26 July 2025).