Getting your ad on TV or your track on the radio used to mean you'd made it.
Distribution was the bottleneck. Attention followed.
Today, you can reach more people from your bedroom than a national agency could in the 90s. But no one celebrates running their first Facebook ad.
That's because distribution is no longer scarce - but attention is.
Emails, promoted posts, sponsored video clips, in-feed whitepapers, chatbot prompts, search ads, retargeting loops: every format is designed to be relevant, and most of it disappears without trace.
The real challenge in B2B marketing isn't access. It's being remembered after the tab closes, the meeting ends, and the buying committee moves on.
But in the race to optimise, most are blending in.
Hyper-targeting isn't the answer
The promise of hyper-targeting was clarity: send the right message to the right person at the right time.
The reality is clutter.
Gartner’s research on B2B buying describes groups working through a set of tasks together. A media platform may only find some of the people doing that work. Audiences move. Buying groups change. And real decision-makers often remain invisible to the data.
Mark Ritson has made the broader case against over-trusting precision targeting for the same reason: the people a platform can target are not the same as the full market that can remember you.
The spreadsheet can make the market look smaller than it is. The people who help you get chosen are not always the people your media platform can find.
What's more, if you only speak to who the spreadsheet tells you to, you miss everyone else - future buyers, influencers, even internal champions.
You narrow your message. You narrow your impact.
Broad targeting may feel inefficient. But it builds memory with more people, more often - and in B2B, that's what wins in the long run.
When everyone optimises, everything looks the same
The problem isn't targeting alone. It's what we do with the data.
Marketing teams under pressure follow the path of least resistance: what's worked before. Best-practice playbooks. The content formats that get clicks. The messaging frameworks that convert.
And if your competitors are doing the same - reading the same reports, chasing the same personas, using the same tools - your campaigns start to converge.
Every whitepaper starts with the same stats. Every landing page says "seamless," "secure," "simple." Every ad uses the same visuals. You're not standing out. You're harmonising.
This is the problem Tom Roach describes when he writes about attention and creativity: efficient delivery means very little if the work itself doesn't earn attention.
Mark Ritson calls a related drift "tactification" - the slide from strategy into a heap of optimised activity.
So you get more iteration.
More default.
More work that looks like marketing before it looks like anything a person might remember.
Data tells you what worked - not what will
Optimisation isn't inherently bad. But it should be the second move, not the first.
Data tells you what happened. It tells you what worked, in what context, for what audience. It doesn't tell you what people haven't seen yet - or what might surprise them.
And the more brands follow the same insights, the less insight any of it has.
It's the paradox of efficiency: by trying to minimise waste, you maximise sameness.
Barry Schwartz called this the Paradox of Choice - an overload of similar options overwhelms decision-making. In B2B, it's more like the paradox of similarity: when everything looks alike, it's easier to ignore all of it.
That's how content overload turns into content apathy.
Optimisation is useful once there is something worth optimising. Used too early, it turns last quarter into a creative brief.
Attention loves difference
To stand out in a saturated environment, difference matters more than precision.
John Dawes uses 95:5 as a rule of thumb. In categories where purchases are infrequent, most potential buyers are out of market at any one time. They can still form memories before they start buying.
And what builds brands? Usually not rational feature lists or gated PDFs.
Campaigns that get remembered give people something to attach to the brand: surprise, emotion, a story, a look, a line, a repeated association.
They earn attention, rather than buying more impressions and hoping memory appears afterwards.
The IPA and WARC work on dull advertising makes the same point from the other side: playing safe can make the media bill do work the creative should have done.
The high cost of playing safe
If your ad looks like an ad, and your blog reads like every other blog, what reason does a buyer have to remember you?
Across whole industries, brands have optimised themselves into invisibility. The result: more spend to achieve the same results.
Or worse - buyers don't just ignore your content, they downgrade their perception of you because of it.
Edelman's research with LinkedIn keeps showing the positive version of this: good thought leadership can help buyers build confidence, persuade colleagues, and shortlist suppliers. In an earlier survey by Edelman and LinkedIn, decision-makers reported that poor thought leadership could cost a supplier credibility and even take it out of consideration.
Distinctiveness doesn't mean guesswork
Being bold doesn't mean being random.
The best creative work is rooted in insight - but it goes beyond what the numbers say.
It sees what the audience sees. It notices what others ignore. It finds the awkward bit in the situation and turns it into something the market can recognise.
The Ehrenberg-Bass distinction between differentiation and distinctiveness is useful here: in crowded categories, being easy to recognise often matters more than proving you are uniquely different.
Recognition is not decoration. It is part of how a buyer finds you again.
This is where creative bravery still needs structure. The point is not to let teams do anything. It is to give them enough room to invent something worth repeating.
Creativity is a commercial multiplier
This isn't about art for art's sake.
When you create media that surprises, moves, or delights your audience, the rest of the system has more to work with.
A remembered ad makes the next message less cold. A distinctive story gives sales something to point to. A recognisable brand makes the product easier to place when the buying conversation starts.
As Stephan Vogel from Ogilvy said:
"Nothing is more efficient than creative advertising. It's more memorable, longer lasting, works with less media spend, and builds a fan community faster."
Even the most advanced data strategy can't fix a campaign no one notices.
Automation makes the decision more important
Generative tools reduce the cost of producing a plausible first version. They can expand routes, adapt formats, and accelerate routine execution. In a category already crowded with familiar language and visual conventions, that efficiency also increases the supply of work with no reason to be remembered.
The constraint moves upstream. Someone still has to choose the problem worth dramatising, the idea the company can defend, the cues it will repeat, and the variation that should be rejected even though it is quick to make. Those are governance decisions before they are production decisions.
Automation is useful when it gives a clear creative direction more reach. Used before that direction exists, it lets the organisation produce its uncertainty at greater speed.
The real bottleneck
We talk about distribution. About precision, reach, optimisation.
But the real bottleneck is attention - and we don't earn it by playing the same tune as everyone else.
In B2B, the practical work is less glamorous and harder to copy.
Be recognisable before the buying window opens.
Make the work distinctive enough to survive the meeting.
Keep carrying the decision after the first awkward reaction.
When production gets easier to automate, taste and commitment become the scarce parts of the system.