B2B companies often fail at marketing because the business keeps making sensible decisions that add up to the wrong system.
Sales wants more opportunities this quarter, finance wants cleaner accountability, product wants clearer messaging, and marketing is asked what will move fastest. Nobody in the room is trying to make bad decisions. That's precisely the problem.
The choices that follow sound commercially mature:
- focus on in-market demand
- tighten targeting
- hold "brand work" for later
- invest where attribution is strongest
- publish more useful content
- ask for more proof before committing
Individually, each decision can be defended. Collectively, they produce a company that gets weaker at creating the conditions for future demand.
Bad Assumptions is about that gap.
How sensible decisions make a weak system
- Defensible choice
- Repeated habit
- Budget and reporting norm
- Weaker market condition
The book follows decisions that are individually reasonable and collectively expensive.
Where weak assumptions cost you
Buying groups revisit tasks as they work towards a decision. They may do some of that work online and some with sales. What one buyer learns still has to make sense to the rest of the group.
Boards and managers want confidence. And confidence often gets represented by the metrics easiest to track, rather than the effects most important to growth.
A company can look active, analytical, and busy while becoming less likely to be remembered in the buying situations that matter, less trusted when risk enters the conversation, and more dependent on force at the point of conversion.
You can do the wrong things, for longer, and feel like you're getting it right.
What this book is
This book is a diagnosis of the assumptions that most often weaken B2B marketing from the inside. It is written for leaders dealing with real constraints: board scrutiny, finite budget, uneven execution, and imperfect data.
What interests me is not whether an individual tactic can work. Most can. The harder question is what the surrounding business teaches marketing to prioritise, repeat, and abandon when pressure arrives.
It is practical without pretending that a few hacks can fix a weak marketing system. It takes performance seriously while resisting the fantasy that every company needs the same budget split, funnel model, or category strategy.
It argues for better commercial judgement around marketing.
You won't need to become a marketing scientist to use this book. You'll need to examine the assumptions behind your current decisions.
The through line
Across every chapter, a single pattern repeats. The business gives prestige to what is immediate, attributable, and defensible. It gives less precedence to what is cumulative, probabilistic, and slower to appear.
So it keeps selecting the form of marketing that feels safest in internal meetings, then wonders why external growth feels harder than expected.
This pattern affects more than campaigns. It shapes culture, teaches teams what gets rewarded, teaches leaders what sounds doable, and teaches marketers which work will survive pressure. Over time, the company builds a narrower theory of growth.
The recurring risk is organisational: decisions that look serious internally can train marketing away from what buyers and markets actually need.
The assumptions this book challenges
Each chapter tackles one assumption that appears reasonable but distorts decisions:
- demand is there, we only need to capture it
- better targeting is always the answer
- brand can wait
- performance is the only real revenue work
- more activity equals better strategy
- positioning is mostly messaging
- more research removes risk
- creative only needs to explain
- I'll know good creative when I see it
- measurable equals true
- social reaction equals market effect
- useful content equals demand strategy
- weak results are mainly marketing's fault
- pricing sits downstream in sales
- ABM is a growth philosophy
- PLG allows marketing to stay lightweight
- PR can substitute for broader market presence
Most of these ideas contain a partial truth. The danger comes when a partial truth gets promoted into a whole-company decision rule.
How better decisions usually look
Better decisions are rarely more complicated. They are usually less confused.
They start with clearer distinctions:
- demand capture versus demand creation
- short-term signal versus long-term contribution
- precision as a tool versus precision as ideology
- measurement for learning versus measurement for show
- content production versus commercial role
- marketing execution issues versus system friction
From there, leaders can ask better questions.
What can we prove this quarter? What are we making more likely over the next four quarters?
Which channel is performing - and what does that mean? What made that channel easier for us?
What should marketing do next? What in the wider business is making growth unnecessarily hard?
This is where judgement matters most. Every approved tactic also sets a condition: what gets funded, what gets measured, what survives pressure, and what the team learns to repeat.
Who this book is for
If you are a founder, CEO, MD, commercial lead, or board-level operator in a B2B company, this book is written for you. If you are a CMO or marketing leader trying to improve the quality of decision-making around marketing, this book is also for you.
The language is commercial on purpose. You will see research-backed reasoning throughout, but translated into decisions you actually have to make: budget, evidence, creative, teams, pricing, and the uncomfortable habit of diagnosing underperformance without defaulting to blame.
How to read it
You can read this book straight through. You can also use it diagnostically.
If your immediate problem is expensive pipeline, read Chapter 1, 2, 4, and 10 first. If your issue is confused messaging and generic work, start with Chapters 6, 7, 8, and 9. If output is high but results are thin, go to Chapters 11, 12, and 13. If commercial pressure keeps collapsing back into discounting or over-focus, read Chapters 14, 15, 16, and 17.